A group of published UK-based authors and illustrators of picture books, children's and YA.
As far as you’re concerned, my writing history looks like this:
To me, my writing history looks like this:
Authors often talk about the projects in our past. Other yet-to-be published writers can draw reassurance from knowing we didn’t just get it right straight off.
My writing past is long and littered with affectionately abandoned projects. There’s the half-started stories written when I was (much) young(er), of the spoiled pony-owner who hated having to let visiting cousins ride her pony, a girl bassist in a band falling for the skater dude singer, the girl who had demon voices urging her to sacrifice one of her classmates… and the three bottom-drawer projects I wrote while looking for my voice.
These are the projects that taught me how to write: how to finish a book; how to plot; the difference between my third- and first-person voice; how much I love a multiple narrative. I grew up and I grew better and I got published.
But there’s an invisible line drawn between what we write before we’re published and what we write after.
Now I’m published the only books that count are the ones other people can read. But this post isn’t about those books – it’s about the ghosts of the ones that haunt the gaps between those published books, the stories I would have written if I didn’t have a publisher.
These are the rejections that come after that first yes – the ones I’m wary of discussing, because that would dispel the illusion that I’m now a successful author.
That’s crap though, obviously. My successes are built on the foundations of my failures in the same way Trouble was built off the back of those three never-to-be-published bottom-drawer novels. Furthermore, pretending that once someone has a publishing deal all their ideas are golden is unhelpful and does nothing for those looking to enter the game.
The fact of the matter is that, for me, editorial rejection doesn’t stop coming. Ever.
Here’s the story in a simple picture:
Only that’s not all the story. Between my first contract and my second, I developed two different ideas, the kind I love the best, that left to my own devices would have been written by now.
BUT writing is no longer my hobby; it’s my job. Jobs are not about being left to your own devices. My editors didn’t like my ideas. One was too gritty. One was way off-brand. With a readership comes expectations and it’s part (not all) of an author’s job to take those expectations into consideration. My editors felt that a Non Pratt books can’t be too bleak (as my first idea was) nor should it be way outside the contemporary zone (if contemporary is Zone 1, idea 2 was up in the Shetland Isles).
So I came up with Truth or Dare. Contract secured. No one needed proof that I could come up with a good idea for the book marked ‘?’ – we’d cross that bridge when we came to it.
A bridge we reached in September 2016… and we’ve yet to cross.
Here are some of the reasons why my ideas for ‘?’ have been rejected:
If you’re wondering how I’ve farted away so much time, it’s because:
So many ideas I’ve loved and lost. Notes scribbled in a book, Post-its on my wall, pitches in my Sent Items folder… and nothing more.
It’s difficult not to get dispirited when you think an idea’s fab and it gets a lukewarm reception. I’m easily dissuaded from the brilliance of my own imagination and the shininess of every idea I had for ‘?’ is tarnished the second I see someone’s brows knit and a question form in their mind. (Oh, external validation, my sweet nemesis.)
But this post isn’t a sympathy-grab. I don’t write to get published; I’m published so I get to write. Being paid to do this is my choice, because it’s the best way to justify how much time I want to spend making stuff up.
So here’s what the last 17 months of failure has taught me:
And the most important thing it’s taught me? That I don’t have to do this, that I can walk away if I want. Being an author is like any other job. You can quit. (Probably not while you’re under contract, though Non…)
Once you know you don’t have to do this, it becomes a choice.
For now, I choose this. This week I’m pitching my best idea yet for ‘?’ and you know what? I think this one I’m actually going to write.
Thanks for this Non. I’m an aspiring author with two projects abandoned at 25k and a third currently at the same point. (Not to mention the other scraps …) Possibly I should focus on what I’ve achieved so far but I am always focused on that point I want to reach. It is lovely to hear about your writing journey. 🙂
Thank you for this. What you say about writing books to follow readers’ expectations from the first book is something I know but have pushed aside. I’m not rethinking if my second book needs to be put aside for now…
This is a really good post.
Thank you for sharing your experience! I always think it’s interesting what happens when things we start with as a passion or hobby turn into a job with a more formalized structure (in this case, because of a contract).
I, for one, look forward to reading bleak Non Pratt one day! 😀 But until then, good luck with your current choice to keep on brand—I’m sure it will result in many more excellent stories.
I love your ghost of an idea. Sometimes they come back for a walk on part. Nothing is ever wasted. Thanks for the great post.
Wonder post, both dismaying (you mean the path isn’t paved with gold once published?) And uplifting for a wannabe like me. Good luck for this idea, and maybe in the execution of writing it any doubts from others will be buried anyway
So true. There is no magic that happens just because you have a contract. But you can write off-brand under another name. (I’ve done that occasionally.) It’s a nice way of sticking with ideas you are devoted to without annoying your publisher. Of course, then you have to do the entire find-a-publisher thing again with your new ID. And it’s not very easy to run one writing career, never mind two…
You’ve no idea how much this cheered me up…thank you! 🙂
The bleak one will almost certainly get written anyway. Its the one idea I can’t seem to let go of!
I’ve hardly enough time for one author identity, let alone two!