AUTHOR ALLSORTS

A group of published UK-based authors and illustrators of picture books, children's and YA.

Where the Boys Are

where-the-boys-are-cartoonf

 

There has been some debate recently about children’s literature in general – and young adult books in particular – as to whether it’s all become a little too girl-centric. What are teen boys to read when so many popular young adult books are written by women? Where are boys to turn when main characters are so often girls?

This conversation makes me cranky.

The reason I get grumpy is because you would never hear these questions posited in reverse. No one ever says, ‘Catcher in the Rye is a great book about a boy written by a man. There’s nothing in it for girls.’

Or, “Hamlet is a bloke; girls will never be interested in that play.’

Girls don’t care

The fact is girls grow up reading mostly books written by and about men. It never occurs to them that they shouldn’t enjoy those books because they don’t have penises. Nor should it occur to them.

Because that would be ridiculous.

Books are gender-free. Books are, if you like, eunuchs. They utterly lack genitalia.

So why are we suddenly, as a society, trying to change this? What is it about 2014 that has made us look around and say, ‘Girls should read books by and about girls. Preferably pink ones. Boys should read books by and about boys. Preferably blue ones. Or at the very least, khaki.’?

When you get right down to it, I guess what I’m saying is, if you ask me “Are there enough YA books for boys?” My reply is: I do not accept the question.

My books have a female main character but an ensemble cast of characters including plenty of boys and men. All the characters kick ass. Literally.

If a boy didn’t read my book – or any other book – because of the gender of the main character or the author, I would feel sorry for that boy. I would also wonder what on earth his future life will be like, given that the world is 50% female.

There’s no escaping us.

Boy looking at girl

Even beyond the confusing and divisive messages this debate sends out to young people, there’s just the sheer frustrating idiocy of it all. I mean it’s farcical, isn’t it? And tragic.

Read without prejudice

Let’s try a thought experiment. Try to imagine your life without books written by – or main characters who are members of – the opposite gender.

For me, that would mean no Holden Caulfield. No Jay Gatsby. No books by Douglas Coupland or Graham Greene. Quite a lot of Shakespeare would be off-limits and most classical texts. I’d never read Slaughterhouse Five or Catch 22.

If you’re a man, you’d not be allowed Dorothy Parker or Mary McCarthy. Margaret Atwood and PD James would also be forbidden to you and all the Brontes. I’m also sorry to say you’d never read Frankenstein.

There are LOTS of books by men

In the end, though, if boys choose to read only books by and about males, there is no shortage of books in that category in the young adult genre. The vast majority of the titles on the New York Times young adult bestseller list were written by men and have male main characters.

There are some who believe this is at least partly a result of the fact that so many boys only read books by men, while girls don’t discriminate. Thus giving male authors a disproportionate likelihood of making young adult bestseller lists.

I hope that’s not true.

I hope young male readers aren’t sexist. And I hope the very existence of this debate doesn’t make them even less likely to read books by women or about girls.

The point of literature is not to read about yourself. The point of literature is to learn about everyone else. To go to places you’ve never been. To discover people you don’t know.

I always say: “Read what you love.” And I still believe that to be a good philosophy.

But if you find you’re only interested in books with your own face on the cover, it might be time to take a look at why that is.

 

C.J. DaughertyCJ Daugherty
Website|Goodreads|Facebook|Twitter
CJ Daugherty is the author of the Night School series of romantic thrillers set in an exclusive boarding school where no one is ever who they seem to be. She is represented by Madeleine Milburn. Her book, Night School: Resistance publishes 5 June in the UK and the US. The series has been translated into 21 languages.

Advertisements

About CJ Daugherty

Former crime reporter CJ Daugherty is the author of the international best-selling Night School series, and the co-author of The Secret Fire. The first book in that series is out now in the UK and the US.

6 comments on “Where the Boys Are

  1. zdmarriott
    May 14, 2014

    Here here!

  2. emmapass
    May 14, 2014

    *fist bump*

  3. Emma Haughton
    May 14, 2014

    So true. Well said!

  4. Pingback: Should boys read boys? | Hihid News

  5. Henry McClave
    June 17, 2014

    ‘So true. Well said.’ No, this is rubbish. An article identifying a problem where there isn’t one, and with a vested interest to boot. I’m well into my 60s and male, but I remember reading and enjoying the great Bronte and Austen classics, as well as Little Women, Jo’s Boys and the rest of them. Never occurred to me that there was a gender issue. They were just good stories.

    Nobody that I know is telling boys to read only ‘boys’ stories’. But maybe there is a shortage of stories being written nowadays in which a boy or boys is the central hero. And maybe the kick-ass girl-hero is just promoting another stereotype, although one favoured by feminists.

    Is there a movement to promote ‘male fiction’. I seriously doubt it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on May 14, 2014 by .

Instagram

Today's post is by @helengrantsays, about feeding your muse. Follow the bio link to read more! #helengrant #creativity #writing #writingblog #authorblogs #authorallsorts On the blog today, @lizdejagerwriter talks social media and shares a page from her gorgeous journal. Follow the bio link to see more! #lizdejager #authors #authorallsorts #authorblogs #writing #journaling #socialmedia #instagram #twitter #facebook

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,187 other followers

Blog Stats

  • 118,793 hits
%d bloggers like this: